Skip to Main Content
It looks like you're using Internet Explorer 11 or older. This website works best with modern browsers such as the latest versions of Chrome, Firefox, Safari, and Edge. If you continue with this browser, you may see unexpected results.

Please note: Children’s Wisconsin recently made a security software change and access to many of MCW Libraries’ electronic resources from the Children’s Wisconsin network is currently blocked. MCW Libraries is aware of the situation and is currently testing new models of access. To access resources blocked on the Children's Wisconsin network, login with your OpenAthens credentials or register for an OpenAthens account here.

Open Access: Evaluation Tools

Provides guidance regarding open access scholarly publishing and information about avoiding predatory publishing

Identifying Predatory Publishers

Identifying predatory journals can be challenging and there's no one indicator that you can rely upon to identify them.  Ultimately, you must make a decision about whether the journal seems legitimate. An MCW Librarian can help give you an additional perspective if you have difficulty deciding.

Warning Signs

Look for these signs when you are assessing whether a journal is suspicious


Journal Title

  • Sounds very similar to a reputable publication
  • Content of the articles in the journal doesn't seem to match the title of the journal or its stated scope
  • Contains words that make the publication seem prestigious (global, international, universal), but don't seem to match with their editorial board members' locations

Indexing

Fees

  • Exact fees are not openly disclosed or easy to locate
  • Journal may require a submission fee, payable whether the article is accepted or not
  • The article processing fees are low; many legitimate open access publishers charge fees, but very low fees are a warning sign

Editorial Board

  • Editors are not familiar to you or do not appear to be people who actually work in that field
  • Contact information for editorial board is not easy to find
  • The editorial board is too small or is not yet established

Web Site

  • Contains a lot of misspellings and errors
  • Looks unprofessional
  • Contains a lot of flashy ads and loud colors

Peer Review

  • Rapid peer review and publication is promised.  It seems too good to be true.
  • No clear peer review policies are stated
  • Journal has no retraction policy

Metrics

MCW Libraries
8701 Watertown Plank Road
Milwaukee, WI 53226
(414) 955-8300

Contact Us
Locations & Hours
Send Us Your Comments