Skip to Main Content

Please Note: Froedtert Health has implemented a new security protocol which has resulted in the degradation of on-campus access to MCW Libraries' electronic resources. Users on the Froedtert network must sign in via OpenAthens when attempting to access electronic library resources (including UpToDate, VisualDx, etc.). MCW Libraries is aware of this change and is working to provide a permanent access solution. If you have MCW credentials, please sign in via MCW employees and students when prompted. If you are a Froedtert employee, click here to register for an OpenAthens account or view more information.

Open Access

Provides guidance regarding open access scholarly publishing and information about avoiding predatory publishing

What is Predatory Publishing?

The term "predatory publishing" was coined by a librarian named Jeffrey Beall to describe open access publishers who were publishing articles with little or no real peer review. Predatory publishers trick authors into believing that they are legitimate publishers that offer the peer review scientists expect in their scholarly journals. These predatory publishers exploit the open access (OA) publishing model to make money from author fees by accepting most or all papers submitted to them.

Predatory publishers are sometimes called "illegitimate publishers" or "suspicious publishers." "Predatory" implies that the blame is all on the publishers, when some authors publish with these journals knowing they are not applying rigorous peer review.

Why is this a problem?

Predatory publishers produce low-quality journals with potentially unvetted, sloppy, or fraudulent articles. Readers of these journals may not recognize the poor quality of the articles. While experienced researchers are likely able to distinguish the authentic science from "junk science," laypersons and students may not recognize the difference. Conclusions and results from poor quality articles are sometimes picked up by mainstream media and represented as fact. This results in unproven theories and myths incorrectly being viewed as fact.

Busy researchers may be fooled by a predatory publisher and mistakenly submit their paper to a low-quality, predatory journal. Authors who publish in predatory journals may find that their papers will be less valued by the scientific community and as a result, less impactful. Additionally, the author fees to publish in predatory journals are steep and will result in poor value for the money spent.

Phony vs legit publishers

Phony vs Legit Publishers Infographic

Click Infographic Image for Larger Version

Evaluating Scholarly Journals Infographic by Allen Press via FrontMatter (CC BY ND NC 3.0) 

MCW Libraries
8701 Watertown Plank Road
Milwaukee, WI 53226
(414) 955-8300

Contact Us
Locations & Hours
Send Us Your Comments